On the Palm Pre

palmpreI’m writing this without ever having actually touched a Palm Pre, but after spending the entire day reading about it, watching videos of it and reading other’s first-hand accounts, I feel fairly confident in saying that I’m excited about it. I’m not excited because I’m going to get one — because I’m not — but I’m excited for all the people who are. And I’m excited because it seems like there is a piece of hardware that could legitimately challenge the iPhone for the first time.

Now before everyone starts screaming “G1″ and “BlackBerry Storm” at me. I’ve used both of those phones — I actually have a G1 sitting right next to me. Anyone who thinks either of those phones is an “iPhone killer” is kidding themselves. Both are leaps and bounds better than most other phones out there, but neither is close to the iPhone when it comes to usability and just plain sexiness. The Palm Pre looks like it could be.

So why does the Pre looks like it will bring the goods? Well first and foremost, it has multi-touch. Doing things like pinch to zoom makes so much more sense than pushing a zoom in or zoom out button like you have to do on phones like the G1. Developers on the iPhone have already proven they can do cool stuff (namely in games) with multi-touch.

Secondly, the Pre has a nice UI. Both the Storm and the G1 fail here in my opinion — and while some will say that UI doesn’t matter, it does matter. Who wants to look at a device multiple times a day that looks like shit? (Hello, Windows Mobile.) No one. The iPhone has a beautiful UI, and the Palm Pre looks like it may even do a few things better (and I’m sure quite a few things worse).

Third, it has a nicer camera than the iPhone and a flash. And yes, it has copy and paste (which I don’t care about nearly as much as some people do).

What I don’t consider to be a factor on the plus side, at least for me, is that it has a physical keyboard. I understand that some people cannot live without a physical keyboard and will bitch up a storm until they get one — as I like to say, it’s kind of like an adult pacifier — but it’s not the future. Apple is right in not caving into those customers who are demanding it. In a few years, none of these smartphones will have physical keyboards. Instead they will have touchscreen-based keyboards with haptic feedback. And people will get used to it, because the physical keyboard is a big waste of space.

But the Pre looks like it does a nice job integrating it as a slide down in vertical mode. Certainly, it looks better than the G1’s shitty keyboard.

Again, I doubt I’m going to get a Pre, but I kind of want one — and that’s something I’ve haven’t felt since the first iPhone launched in 2007. I think it’s good if the iPhone has a competitor on the market, it will push it (and all phones) to continually get better. That’s a win for us, the consumers.

Will it save Palm? Who knows. But they put on one hell of a show today that has the Internet in a tizzy. That’s a great start to rebuilding something that was lost several years ago. Remember, Apple had to do that once too.

  • ern0
    Try Palm Tungsten C's keyboard, it's the best thumbboard ever (now I am using Treo 650, which is usable).
  • The Palm Pre looks great, but I do worry that there won't be any cool software for it... They laid off most of their business development and developer relations team last month. And, they use PocketGear to power their app store, which doesn't offer as good a revenue split to developers as Apple does or Android Market and the Blackberry App store reportedly will. I really want Palm to succeed, but so much of what makes a great phone (in my opinion) is the post-loaded software.
  • It seems just as awesome without any third-party software. The UI is really nice, and intuitive/functional— far more usable than the current iPhone. Still, l hope Palm attracts a large number of app developers.
  • I have that crappy Instinct, so i can't wait until this comes out.
  • Yeah, getting developers to develop for it will be key in its adoption after the initial wave Lisa. But indications are that they're doing the right things now to at least try to woo developers -- and I'm not talking about that silly PocketGear app store :) We'll see...
  • Indications seem to be that Palm is learning from past mistakes rather than repeating them. But again, time will tell.
  • I agree Palm is off to a good start with the Pre. Though, it'll be hard to woo developers away from other development platforms unless Palm changes the value proposition of its app store. PocketGear (the old Motricity) powers the new, on-device "Palm App Catalog". Palm announced the Palm App Catalog in late 08, so I don't imagine it'll change soon. 3rd party distribution channels that *might* support Palm WebOS (i.e. Handmark, Handango, the new Motricity, etc.) have similar rev share and app submission models. Fingers crossed things change and Palm builds a solid business case for Mojo development and distribution in the coming months.
  • abcyesn
    The Palm Pre is a lot smaller than I initially thought it would be. A good size comparison would be an iPod classic with a big hard drive. In terms of thickness, it's definitely not as thin as the iPhone, or even the bold, but it's an acceptable size considering it's a slider.

    talk some more here http://www.PalmPreForum.org
blog comments powered by Disqus