On The Kindle

picture-2I have a confession to make: After months of ripping the device, I bought a Kindle the other day. And I really like it.

Now, let me be clear: The reasons I ripped it still remain. The thing is entirely too expensive at $360 and I still don’t believe that it can survive long term as phones and tablet computers will destroy its place in the market. But for now, it’s a very nice piece of tech if you can afford it.

So why did I get one? As you may have guessed from my job (blogging), I do quite a bit of reading every single day on the Internet. While I love that, it has pretty much killed my desire to read books/magazines/anything else. But, when I learned the Kindle offered support for Instapaper, a great, simple bookmarking tool that I use to save things to read later, I was immediately sold.

While I love reading stuff online, it really takes a toll on your eyes, obviously. And with the iPhone now on me at all times, that problem is even worse as you’re reading it on a much smaller screen. At night, I lay in bed and read articles that I saved to Instapaper on my iPhone screen — that just wasn’t cutting it. But the Kindle with Instapaper support is genius. Because the display doesn’t have a backlight and uses e-ink, it isn’t like reading on a digital screen at all, but instead is like reading a book or a newspaper — regular print, without any of the print residue. And, thanks to no backlight, you can actually read it outside in sunlight.

Okay, that’s a great feature for someone like me, but still nowhere near worth a $360 price tag. But, now that I’ve been using it for a few days I think I have a new favorite feature: Text-to-speech. Like most people, I thought this might be a lame gimmick of the new Kindle 2, but having used it now fairly extensively, I can safely say that I love it. Sure, it’s far from perfect, but it’s pretty damn good. Especially when I find myself laying it bed wanting to read but sick of reading after doing it all day. Yes, it works with things saved on Instapaper as well.

If the Kindle were like $99, I think it would be one of the hottest devices out there. If it were $199, it’d be a pretty solid buy. But at $360, I still only recommend it if you either love reading (but don’t care about having physical books), or are in pretty much the same boat as myself, as I described above.

I still doubt the Kindle will exist in 5 years, but for now it’s a pretty nice tool that has so far been able to drag me away from my computer and even the iPhone. At least for 30 minutes a day.

  • I have a bad habit of saving all kinds of stuff to Instapaper and then never going back and reading it. I like the idea of InstaPaper on the iPhone but, similar to your experience, it's not a very enjoyable experience. I'm still not so sure about the $360 price tag but you've just about convinced me that I need to get one of these things.
  • One word of caution is that there is a bug right now preventing your from logging into Instapaper from the Kindles (pretty crappy) web browser. Instead, I use the "official" beta way of using Instapaper on the Kindle, which involves emailing your shared item to your Kindle. Unfortunately, Amazon LAMELY charges you 10 cents each time you email something to the device. I'll be interested to see how this adds up for me. Just something else to know before making the jump -- hopefully they fix the bug preventing you from logging into the web page.
  • Good to know - thanks!
  • Al
    I don't have an iPhone as I cannot justify the $1800+ price over the next two years and then more after that. I got the Kindle because it is only $360 plus $30 case. I use the font size 4 to 6 depending on light and freshness of eyes. I really like that I have to charge it only once per week or so. I also like the ability to turn off the cell phone portion so that it no longer emits EMF into my body. There are hundreds of free books that one can read on the Kindle. I use the computer to read the complicated PDFs, ones that have tables for example and convert the rest to TXT or Kindle files to read on the Kindle. On some of the TXT conversions I have had to open them in my word processor and remove the hard returns to make the lines flow properly, but that is not a big deal. I like reading outside and cannot do that on my laptop nor on my Palm Pilot. I don't think the Kindle is for everybody, but surely is for the elderly, the handicapped and anyone else that needs a large print book or cannot hold a big book easily. I also have all the books I want to read now and in the near future on my Kindle, with lots more waiting on the computer to just nudge over there when I am ready to read them. I don't read news so I don't care about the newspapers or magazines on the Kindle, just books and check lists and notes and shopping lists and anything else I choose to put on there.
  • Thats quite a compelling argument, as my non-interweb reading has sunk over the years. $360 though? Harumph.
  • Yeah, price sucks for sure.
  • So what have you purchased so far for the Kindle? Just books or magazines or are you literally just using it for Instapaper?
  • "I still don’t believe that it can survive long term as phones and tablet computers will destroy its place in the market"

    I have e-ink book reader, N810 tablet and mobile phone. Book reader provides much better reading experience than either of other. Because it's made for reading books, not for browsing Internet and comparing gadget sizes.

    There are plenty of people like me who are willing to pay for good reading experience without caring that latest phonogadget will have more whistles and make them look more cool. :)
  • test #giannii
  • Facebook User
    testing a reply as a facebook user. please delete this comment.
  • Hmmmm, thanks for the tip about Instapaper; didn't know that was on the Kindle. But yeah - $360 is pretty cost prohibitive for most folks, especially when you add in all the content you'd have to buy (I can buy a lot of books for $360) - plus the odds that Amazon will surely feel pressure to lower the price of the Kindle with all these netbooks.

    If the Kindle were $100 I'd buy one today, until then I can make do with the iPhone Kindle app and just ruin my eyes for a few more months :)
  • Charging incoming mails ? How dull this business model can be ?
    Thats pre-Google-era business model , sms style business model!
    Hate ripoffs !
  • thanks a lot for sharing! Really useful comment and I'm almost buying one; if it was a bit less expensive...

    What about reading PDFs on the kindle? I know it doesn't officially support PDFs, but was wondering if there's a way to convert it like on InstaPaper...
  • brady
    MG, aren't you feeling additional eye strain? I upgraded and am dying (ok not literally) over here.
  • I write blogs for a site called www.eldergadget.com and I discovered that according to the findings of a new survey, over half of reporting Kindle owners are 50 or older, and 70 percent are 40 or older. The comments themselves are as illuminating as the numbers. So many users said they like Kindle because they suffer from some form of arthritis.A variety of other impairments, from weakening eyes and carpal-tunnel-like syndromes to more exotic disabilities dominate the purchase rationales of these posters. Countless people report being able to read much more with Kindle because it overcomes physical obstacles or limitations that had made reading difficult for them previously. The Kindle seems ideal for an older generation who loves to read and has time to do it.
  • Nice post
  • Guest
    A variety of other impairments, from weakening eyes and carpal-tunnel-like syndromes to more exotic disabilities dominate the purchase rationales of these posters. gucciwell.com
blog comments powered by Disqus