About this site

Howdy, I'm MG Siegler. I’m a general partner at CrunchFund and a columnist for TechCrunch. This is where I collect things.

Recent Tweets

Liked on Tumblr

More liked posts

Foursquare Adds Another Search Feature: Check-In History

In my mind, Foursquare history remains one of the most interesting features of the service. It knows basically everywhere I’ve been since 2009 (actually, 2008 thanks to some imported Dodgeball data). To some, that’s creepy — to me, that’s awesome.

Recommendations are the obvious use case for past data. But as we’re seeing with services ranging from Facebook Timeline to Timehop, don’t underestimate the power of nostalgia. 

Tags tech foursquare location

Meeting People Is Easy, Remembering Them Is Hard, Knowing Them Is Harder

I understood the value of Highlight immediately. Within hours of downloading the app, I walked into a cafe and ran into someone I had met before, but only in passing. Who was he, I wondered while talking to him in vague generalities so as not to give away my poor recognition skills. It was a pretty pointless conversation that perhaps could have been a great one if I could have just remembered who the hell he was.

I sat down and pulled out my phone which had been buzzing since I entered the cafe. There, right in front of me in the form of a push notification was the name of the guy I was just talking to. I swiped it and got taken into Highlight where I could see his picture, where he worked, and our common friends. Brilliant.

Ideally, of course, I’d check the notification before I talked to the guy. But that’s my own fault. I was new to this. You get the idea. And this is just one potential value of Highlight.

The service, which CrunchFund has invested in, pushed a major app update today to gear up for SXSW. They know the potential this app has there. My first conversation with Highlight co-founder Paul Davison immediately went in that direction. “This is going to kill it at SXSW,” I believe were my words.

But as repeat offenders know, SXSW is now a very noisy time to launch an app. Twitter and Foursquare had it easier when they found success in Austin a few years ago. Thanks to that success, the event has become a launch platform for apps. Last year it was group messaging services (GroupMe, Beluga, Yobongo — all of which, coincidentally, have now been acquired). This year it’s the passive location apps, of which Highlight is one. There are many others. Several of them are also strong apps. It’s going to take an app really extraordinary to stand out in the crowd.

The truth, of course, is that passive location apps are not new. It’s the way that apps like Google Latitude started. And Loopt has been doing it for a long time. But it’s one of those situations where the initial wave was too early. The check-in apps — namely Foursquare — came in like a buzzsaw and cut down the passive apps. 

But good ideas that don’t work the first time find a way. Our technology is more advanced now than it was even just a few years ago. Back then, the iPhone couldn’t do background location (or, more accurately, Apple wouldn’t allow it to do background location due to battery concerns). Now it can. Hence, Highlight and all the competitors.

The reason why Highlight is exciting to me is because it has the potential to be a lot of things. I get the feeling that like Twitter and other social services, the users will end up determining the best use case. The Highlight team have features they’ve implemented based on how they think people will want to use it. But the truth is that no one really knows.

My initial example is one use case. I’ve used it a dozen or so times over the past several weeks as a refresher course before saying hello to someone. 

But not everyone is as bad at remembering names as I am. Instead, they might find Highlight useful simply to know when friends are nearby. You can obviously do this on Foursquare — as I have been since day one — but that puts the burden on someone else to check-in. If they don’t, you won’t know that they’re nearby. 

The check-in had to come first because it eased people into the idea of sharing their location. It’s a very explicit action. It has now been around long enough where it’s time to evolve to passive location for certain use cases. Of course, this will freak some people out. But in a couple years it will be the norm. Just like checking-in is today.

Another interesting thing I’ve noticed while using Highlight: there are people I am near all the time that I’ve never actually met. We’re in the same cafes every day but we never speak. And that’s fine — I don’t like talking to total strangers, I’m sure most people are the same way. But if we’re in the same spots often and we have several mutual friends, which Highlight tells us, it gets interesting. And maybe we have interests in common too.

In a regular social setting, if the mutual friend was present, they’d introduce us. Highlight can act as a virtual representation of your mutual friend in this case.

Still, that’s a bit weird to think about, I admit. But one of the new features that Highlight launched today — appropriately called “Highlighting” — can help nudge this notion along. You can now highlight people you think are interesting and they’ll see it (who you highlight is public on profiles, which was probably a tough call, but the right one, I think). It’s a lightweight interaction — perfect if you don’t want to message someone (which you can do as well in the app), or, god forbid, get up and go talk to them. 

Maybe this spurs interaction. Or maybe people won’t use the feature that way.

Seeing how people using the highlighting feature will be fascinating. At SXSW, you meet so many people for brief moments of time. Thousands, tens of thousands, hundreds of thousands business cards trade hands. Most people will never look at those business cards again. I never do. I hate business cards. Why not just highlight someone you met that you found interesting? The best thing is that only one of you has to do anything because again, both sides can see the highlight. 

Maybe that use case doesn’t scale at SXSW. Or maybe it does. Or maybe it just doesn’t catch on. Maybe it evolves into some sort of flirting thing. Again, the community will decide, which is exciting.

Or maybe highlighting is a niche thing that a small percentage of users end up doing. Maybe the main benefit of Highlight (the service) is simply to be passive in the background and only alert you when you want it to (a friend is nearby, for example). I love the trend we’re seeing of apps that work without you having to explicitly interact with them. Foursquare Radar is another great example of this.

My main concern for Highlight at SXSW is the noise. In San Francisco, I get maybe 10 Highlight notifications a day (they’re smart about how they do it, and don’t do it every time you’re near someone — and they’re getting smarter about it over time). In Austin, I’m worried I’ll get 1,000 notifications as every geek on the planet crams into a couple mile radius. I know they’ve thought a lot about this issue. Can’t wait to see what happens.

I also worry about the battery life of my phone. Forget privacy fears, this is the real downside of these passive location apps, in my opinion. The latest version of Highlight is the most optimized yet for battery life. It knows to rest until there’s a major location change, for example. 

I’m still bringing two Mophie battery packs with me.

I swore I wasn’t going to go to SXSW this year. I say that every year. And yet, every year I go. But this year I’m actually excited. I’m excited to see how Highlight gets used in its first big test. And I’m excited to talk to Dennis Crowley about all of this on stage at 3:30 PM Saturday in Exhibit Hall 5.

Longest promo for a talk ever.

Tags crunchfund foursquare highlight startups sxsw tech on

Foursquare Ditches Google Maps For OpenStreetMaps

This is interesting because maps are obviously a vital part of location-based services. And while a few have picked Bing Maps over Google Maps, I can’t recall any service as big as Foursquare, which was using Google for so long, ditching them in favor of the open alternative (as they note, several smaller startups have, often due to cost — which was also why Foursquare started looking for other alternatives).

Worth noting that this only impacts the Foursquare website right now — the iPhone and Android apps will continue to use Google Maps since both of those OSes offer Google Maps in their SDKs.

But that brings up something else: how long is Apple going to stick with Google Maps? At the time of the iPhone launch, it was really the only good solution (and they had a great relationship with Google). Now there are several options (and the Google relationship has gone to shit).

I think it’s quite possible that the only reason Apple hasn’t switched to another alternative at this point is because they continue to work on their own solution.

Tags tech foursquare google maps apple openstreetnaps

Google Quietly Tries To Compete With Foursquare Of Three Years Ago

A few years ago, this would have been interesting. But now it just looks foolish. It looks like a company that’s so embarrassed about how late they are to the dance that they snuck in the backdoor and refuse to talk to anyone let alone dance with anyone. 

Google made a big bet on background location with Latitude, but they were far too early. By the time they realized this and pivoted towards the check-in, it was too late. Now things are finally starting to shift towards background location and Google is going the wrong way.

Tags tech location google latitude foursquare

"Why Now?"

Nice quick post by Chris Dixon reflecting on why certain web-based marketplaces are taking off now when they haven’t in the past. The key:

I asked Roelof Botha the “why now” question regarding web-based marketplaces. He said something I thought was really interesting: marketplaces depend on trust, and trust requires knowing the reputation of a prospective counterparty. Today, for the first time, you can get background information on almost any prospective counterparty by searching Google, Facebook etc. Or put more simply: we finally have an internet of people.

One of my favorite things about Airbnb is the way they handle reputation by looking at your social connections. If thousands of people follow me on Twitter and I have hundreds of friends on Facebook, I’m probably not an impostor looking for trouble. Square does some of this as well, I believe.

More broadly, “why now” is often just a matter of timing. I think of Dodgeball, which never took off in the way Foursquare has even though they’re essentially the same thing (or at least started that way). Sure, you can probably partially blame Google for neglecting Dodgeball post-acquisition, but a bigger key was the rise of smartphones, and the iPhone with its app marketplace in particular. 

Dodgeball was a great idea. Foursquare exploded because it was a great idea at the right time.

Tags tech chris dixon startups foursquare dodgeball airbnb square

The continued evolution of the Foursquare game. I love this (mostly because I’m winning and was called both “Juan Valdez” and achieved “Jedi Status”). More importantly, this automatically converts badges into something more meaningful. 
Finally, all that wine drinking and sushi eating will pay off — at least for someone else in the form of automatic recommendations. 
I’m still holding out hope for my last remaining gaming feature request: Mayorships amongst friends. You basically can’t get mayorships in popular spots in major cities. Too many people are playing. But if you could just battle your social graph, I think that would drive interesting combative social behavior, hearkening back to the early days of Foursquare. 

The continued evolution of the Foursquare game. I love this (mostly because I’m winning and was called both “Juan Valdez” and achieved “Jedi Status”). More importantly, this automatically converts badges into something more meaningful

Finally, all that wine drinking and sushi eating will pay off — at least for someone else in the form of automatic recommendations. 

I’m still holding out hope for my last remaining gaming feature request: Mayorships amongst friends. You basically can’t get mayorships in popular spots in major cities. Too many people are playing. But if you could just battle your social graph, I think that would drive interesting combative social behavior, hearkening back to the early days of Foursquare. 

Tags tech foursquare

marsbot:

Icon-olution
As mentioned in a previous post about the evolution of our iphone app, one of the great things about working at a start up is the ability to iterate and the speed at which you can do this. As we strive to improve our product, we wanted to make sure we had an icon that reflected the current state of our brand. 
To achieve this, we made a few subtle changes to the icon as opposed to a big change. This didn’t feel like the appropriate time to do a complete revolution; an evolution felt more apt. 
You’ll notice we’ve rounded and softened the edges to better align with other illustrative elements you find in our app such as badges and icons. We’ve replaced the purple ball with a green ball, as purple no longer lives in our color palette elsewhere in the app or site. Green is one of our primary colors and we wanted that represented here. We’ve also gone back to a less perfectly parallel trail of the ball (which also makes our iconic check mark) to inject a more playful feel into the icon while still maintaining our clean edges and lines. 

Attention to detail. Very nice.
Update: Dennis Crowley shares more history about the logo.

marsbot:

Icon-olution

As mentioned in a previous post about the evolution of our iphone app, one of the great things about working at a start up is the ability to iterate and the speed at which you can do this. As we strive to improve our product, we wanted to make sure we had an icon that reflected the current state of our brand. 

To achieve this, we made a few subtle changes to the icon as opposed to a big change. This didn’t feel like the appropriate time to do a complete revolution; an evolution felt more apt. 

You’ll notice we’ve rounded and softened the edges to better align with other illustrative elements you find in our app such as badges and icons. We’ve replaced the purple ball with a green ball, as purple no longer lives in our color palette elsewhere in the app or site. Green is one of our primary colors and we wanted that represented here. We’ve also gone back to a less perfectly parallel trail of the ball (which also makes our iconic check mark) to inject a more playful feel into the icon while still maintaining our clean edges and lines. 

Attention to detail. Very nice.

Update: Dennis Crowley shares more history about the logo.

Tags tech foursquare

Reblogged from mari sheibley  Source marsbot

marsbot:

An evolution of foursquare design from January 2009 - August 2011
One of the great things about working on one product is the ability to iterate; the bad thing is you never feel like you’re done. 
When foursquare started there was no real visual design on the app. Naveen was coding it up alone and he used all native Apple UI elements. I was helping out on the side and slowly we added custom elements and branding and for SXSW 2010 we did our first visual pass at the design. At that point I was doing everything, and it showed. One person can only do so much. Now we have a talented group of UI and UX designers and these days I mostly work on the iOS app. We just put out a new build complete with a new blue navigation bar, photos inline, single tap cells and a newly designed check-in detail screen. I’m really proud of this current iteration of the app and can’t wait to see it continue to evolve. 
view larger

This sort of reminds me of looking at the high school yearbook photos of an old friend.
I’m sure glad Foursquare has shaved that moustache and cut that mullet.

marsbot:

An evolution of foursquare design from January 2009 - August 2011

One of the great things about working on one product is the ability to iterate; the bad thing is you never feel like you’re done. 

When foursquare started there was no real visual design on the app. Naveen was coding it up alone and he used all native Apple UI elements. I was helping out on the side and slowly we added custom elements and branding and for SXSW 2010 we did our first visual pass at the design. At that point I was doing everything, and it showed. One person can only do so much. Now we have a talented group of UI and UX designers and these days I mostly work on the iOS app.

We just put out a new build complete with a new blue navigation bar, photos inline, single tap cells and a newly designed check-in detail screen. I’m really proud of this current iteration of the app and can’t wait to see it continue to evolve. 

view larger

This sort of reminds me of looking at the high school yearbook photos of an old friend.

I’m sure glad Foursquare has shaved that moustache and cut that mullet.

Tags tech foursquare design

Reblogged from mari sheibley  Source marsbot